September 25, 2026
One name in the group earns the neglect. Two others are a different story.
Hey there, bargain hunter. While everyone is watching the Magnificent Seven hit new records and debating whether the 10-year Treasury yield near 5% is a ceiling or a floor, the most contrarian positioning signal in the September BofA Global Fund Manager Survey has gone almost unnoticed. Consumer staples just became the most unloved sector on the planet.
61% of Americans Worry America Could be on the Verge of Another Civil War
Today, more than half of America thinks a civil war is likely.
Former CIA Advisor Jim Rickards agrees.
He just uncovered a fascinating plot by Trump to keep the Democrats out of the White House until 2033.
And while he believes it could be successful, it could also trigger America’s Second Civil War.
Scoreboard
Consumer staples fell to a net 33% underweight, the most bearish positioning since January 2004. That is a 22-year extreme. Meanwhile, the Roundhill Magnificent Seven ETF (MAGS) is higher by about 5% this month through midweek trading, far more than the S&P 500’s slight advance over the same time period. The tech giants surged to all-time highs this week, a surprising show of strength given that the group had floundered for much of this year.
Cash holdings rose to 3.9% of assets from 3.5% in August, the largest monthly increase since March 2026. September saw rotation into healthcare, industrials, and banks, which reached their most overweight position since November 2025. The money coming out of bonds is not flowing into Tide and Cheerios. It is going into Nvidia and Meta.
The healthcare overweight is not a new theme — institutional money began moving there months before this survey confirmed it. the Bank of America upgrade of UnitedHealth that signaled the start of the healthcare rotation shows how early the smart money positioned, and how much runway that trade may still have relative to the crowded Magnificent Seven.
The Real Reason
There is another reason investors are drawn to the Magnificent Seven: the group’s scale, cash flow, and balance sheets make it a safe haven in a rising interest rate environment that can punish both stocks and bonds. The 10-year Treasury yield has recently been around 5% after rising sharply over the past few months, and managers are treating hyperscalers as the new bond proxy. Staples, the old bond proxy, got left holding the bag.
The disagreement over where yields go from here is not just an academic debate — it is splitting Wall Street’s biggest institutions in real time. how JPMorgan and Goldman are taking opposite sides of the 5% yield trade is worth understanding before making any sector call that depends on rates reversing.
The sector’s macro playbook is simple: XLP outperforms in late-cycle and recession regimes when defensives rotate higher, and underperforms in expansion when risk appetite rises. Right now, risk appetite is up, yields are up, and staples are getting crushed from both sides.
What is “The Presidio Initiative”?
A single $20 million check delivered to a former military base may have launched the biggest megaproject in American history.
The Sector Breakdown: Who Deserves the Neglect
Not every staples name is created equal. The 22-year underweight is a blunt instrument, and the bargain-hunting opportunity depends entirely on which name you are looking at.
Costco (COST): The one that earns its premium. For the full fiscal year 2026, Costco reported $303.15 billion in revenue, up 10.1% year over year, and GAAP EPS of $20.76. Operating income rose 12.5% to $11.69 billion, and free cash flow expanded 19.8% to $9.39 billion. Q4 GAAP EPS of $6.75 beat expectations, with total revenue of $93.9 billion rising 11.2% year over year. Comparable sales rose 9.4%, with comparable traffic up 3.3% and digitally-enabled comparable sales up 19.5%. The problem: Costco still trades at roughly 45x forward earnings. That is not a staples valuation. That is a growth stock dressed in a food court apron. At ~45x in a ~5% yield world, Costco is not a bargain; it is a quality compounder you pay up for deliberately.
Procter & Gamble (PG): Cheap-ish, but the growth problem is real. P&G reported fiscal year 2026 net sales of $87.0 billion, an increase of 3% versus the prior year. The company generated operating cash flow of $19.6 billion for the fiscal year. That cash generation is genuine. Fiscal 2027 guidance projects 1-3% organic sales growth and 0-3% core EPS growth to $6.89-$7.11, with $1 billion in after-tax cost headwinds expected. One percent organic growth against a $1 billion cost wall is not a springboard. The business is durable; the stock’s re-rating potential is limited until volume acceleration shows up.
General Mills (GIS): The one that actually justifies the neglect. For the full fiscal year ended May 31, 2026, net sales declined 5% to $18.4 billion. Q1 fiscal 2027, reported two days ago, was no better: net sales fell 3%, and organic net sales were flat as price and mix improvements were offset by a 1% decline in organic volume. Fiscal 2027 organic net sales guidance ranges from down 1.5% to up 0.5%, and adjusted operating profit is expected to decline 8%-13% in constant currency. GIS is cheap on price-to-sales. It is cheap for a reason.
He Found Rolls-Royce Below $2. Now He’s Found His Second Unicorn.
In 2022, one man identified Rolls-Royce below $2 before shares later climbed above $10.
Now he says he’s seeing similar fingerprints in another company: billions in operating income, rapid growth, a low valuation and a powerful AI-energy catalyst.
Is XLP Worth Owning Here?
XLP offers a dividend yield around 2.66%. Against a ~5% 10-year, that yield does not scream value. The ETF is a blunt tool: you get Costco at ~45x alongside GIS at its worst fundamental stretch in years.
Bull / Base / Bear
- Bull: Yields reverse below 4.5%, recession fears spike, and the classic defensive playbook reasserts itself. XLP squeezes sharply from a 22-year underweight base.
- Base: Yields stay elevated, rotation continues toward healthcare and industrials, staples drift sideways with dividend support providing a floor.
- Bear: Consumer spending deteriorates without a recession catalyst for defensive rotation. Volume declines at GIS and P&G deepen, and the sector de-rates further.
Gauging whether that bear case is approaching requires watching actual consumer spending data, not just macro forecasts. what American Express Q2 results revealed about the health of the high-end spender offers a ground-level read on whether the spending resilience underpinning the bull case for risk assets is beginning to crack.
Action Plan
The 22-year positioning extreme is real signal, not noise. But sector-level contrarianism is only half the trade. Be selective. PG at current prices, with $19.6 billion in operating cash flow and a yield above 2.9%, gives you durable cash generation while you wait for the rotation. Avoid GIS until organic volume turns positive for two consecutive quarters. Skip XLP as a blunt vehicle when Costco’s ~45x forward multiple distorts the value picture.
Cheap Investor Scorecard
- Consumer staples fund manager positioning: net 33% underweight, 22-year extreme. Watch for mean reversion toward -15%.
- XLP dividend yield vs. 10-year spread: currently negative. Re-enter conviction when spread flips positive.
- P&G FY2027 organic sales: watch for sustained acceleration above 2% to justify multiple expansion.
- GIS organic volume: down 1% in Q1 FY27. Needs two positive quarters before the value case solidifies.
- MAGS vs. XLP relative performance: about a 5% September gap. Monitor for compression as a rotation signal.
- 10-year Treasury yield: recently around 5%. Staples re-rate when this falls below 4.5%.
- Costco comparable sales growth: 9.4% in Q4 FY26. Premium warranted; ~45x forward P/E is the price of admission.
- BofA cash levels: 3.9%, just below the 4% contrarian re-risk threshold.
Bottom Line
If yields stay around 5% and the economy holds, the Magnificent Seven keeps eating staples’ lunch and the 22-year underweight goes unresolved. If growth stumbles or yields drop 60-plus basis points, that 22-year positioning extreme becomes one of the fastest mean-reversion trades available. The sector as a whole does not deserve a blanket buy; P&G earns selective accumulation on weakness, GIS does not yet, and Costco is a different conversation at ~45x. Know what you own before the rotation arrives.
